Courts uphold €250,000 in fines on Acciona for serious breaches of Torrevieja waste contract
Why it matters: Courts upheld €250,000 in fines on Acciona for very serious breaches of Torrevieja’s waste contract. The €100,000 penalty will be deducted from payments for the service. The second ruling is first-instance and may be appealed.
Details:
- The courts backed the Ayuntamiento de Torrevieja (town hall) in two cases against Acciona over penalties totalling €250,000 for very serious breaches of the municipal waste and cleaning contract.
- One case concerned a €100,000 penalty; Acciona lost appeals at both first instance and on appeal, and must pay €500 in costs at first instance and a further €2,500 on appeal.
- A second case covers three penalties of €50,000 each, totalling €150,000; Acciona’s appeal was rejected, the ruling was described as firm, but it is a first-instance procedure and Acciona will most likely appeal to the Tribunal Superior de Justicia de la Comunidad Valenciana (TSJCV).
- The TSJCV previously validated another €135,000 fine, so Acciona now has €335,000 in penalties backed by court rulings.
- Breaches included failing to maintain the required minimum staff during the summer, with the contract requiring around 400 workers but only 300 provided.
- Acciona receives over €25 million annually for the 15-year contract, awarded in June 2022; Actúa (Hozono Global) now holds a 50% share.
What it means for you: The €100,000 penalty will be deducted from payments to Acciona for the service. The ruling on the €150,000 in fines was described as firm, but it is a first-instance procedure and further appeal is likely.
The source article appears to be truncated.
Courts uphold fines for contract breaches
The courts have confirmed €250,000 in penalties imposed by the Ayuntamiento de Torrevieja (town hall) on Acciona for very serious breaches of the municipal waste collection and street cleaning contract. The Local Government Board was informed of the court decisions on Friday, 13 November, according to councillor and board secretary Federico Alarcón.
What the rulings cover
One case involved a €100,000 penalty imposed by the Ayuntamiento. Acciona challenged the decision, but the court dismissed its appeal at first instance and ordered it to pay €500 in costs. Acciona appealed again and lost, incurring a further €2,500 in costs. The €100,000 will be deducted from payments to Acciona for providing the service.
The second case concerned three penalties of €50,000 each, totalling €150,000, also for very serious breaches. The court rejected Acciona’s appeal and imposed €500 in costs. The ruling was described as firm, but it is a first-instance procedure and, according to Alarcón, Acciona will most likely appeal to the Tribunal Superior de Justicia de la Comunidad Valenciana (TSJCV), as it has done repeatedly in the past. The TSJCV previously validated another €135,000 fine, so Acciona now has €335,000 in penalties backed by court rulings.
Background: staff shortages and contract issues
The fines follow municipal investigations into breaches of the contract, which were first made public in 2024. Infringements included failing to maintain the minimum required staff during the high season: the contract required about 400 workers in summer, but Acciona provided only around 300. Earlier penalties for minor and serious breaches in 2023 totalled €275,005, with an additional case for unprovided services between June and December 2023 valued at €577,547. Since then, penalties have decreased after Acciona made corrections, especially in staffing, but it still breaches many contract conditions, sanctioned as minor irregularities.
Acciona receives over €25 million annually from the Ayuntamiento for the 15-year contract, awarded in June 2022. Recently, Actúa (part of Hozono Global) took a 50% share in the contract. Despite some improvements in daily cleaning and collection, the contract’s results have not met the expectations of residents or the municipality.
Source: Informacion.ES ↗ · Discuss on Telegram ↗