Saturday, 21 November 2026 · Torrevieja 13° · sea 20°ENUKESTelegram ↗
Laws & paperwork · Torrevieja ·

Supreme Court criticises Torrevieja judge for 'copy-pasting' arguments from foreign sources

Photo: Infobae

Why it matters: The Supreme Court criticised a Torrevieja judge for copying arguments from foreign sources without explaining their relevance. The Supreme Court dismissed the applicant's appeal and ordered him to pay court costs.

Details:

  • The Supreme Court of Spain criticised a Torrevieja judge for 'copy-pasting' arguments from foreign sources.
  • The judge rejected a request to combine three criminal proceedings in December 2020.
  • He used arguments from Peruvian Supreme Court member César San Martín and 15 pages from an article by professor Cubillo López.
  • The Supreme Court said judicial decisions must have specific reasoning, not just copied academic or doctrinal texts.
  • The Alicante provincial court upheld the Torrevieja decision in 2021.
  • The Supreme Court dismissed the cassation appeal and ordered the applicant to pay court costs.

Based on the @torreUA summary; original source not available.

Spain’s Supreme Court has criticised a judge in Torrevieja for 'copy-pasting' arguments from foreign sources in a ruling. The case involved the judge’s decision in December 2020 to reject a request to combine three criminal proceedings. According to Infobae, the judge almost verbatim used reasoning from Peruvian Supreme Court member César San Martín and included 15 pages from an article by professor Cubillo López, without explaining how these materials related to the case.

The Supreme Court stated that judicial decisions must be supported by specific reasoning, not simply by copying academic or doctrinal texts. The Alicante provincial court upheld the Torrevieja judge’s decision in 2021. The Supreme Court also noted that the applicant did not properly justify the need to combine the proceedings or what harm was caused. The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal and ordered the applicant to pay court costs.

More from Torrevieja

Related